鶹Ժ


This article has been reviewed according to Science X's and . have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

fact-checked

peer-reviewed publication

trusted source

proofread

Timid tinkerers: Shy mice are more persistent problem-solvers, study finds

Shy mice are more persistent problem-solvers
A house mouse in a targeted attempt to solve an experimental problem. Credit: MPI f. Evolutionary Biology/Alexandros Vezyrakis

Why do some animals solve problems while others don't? The new study from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology, now on the cover of Oikos, tackles this question with an unexpected star: the wild house mouse. This research dives into how different personality types—especially traits like boldness and shyness—influence innovation.

Led by Alexandros Vezyrakis, with Anja Guenther and Valeria Mazza, the team tested over 100 both in semi-natural enclosures (mimicking their wild habitats) and later in controlled lab arenas. The result? Shyer mice, not the bold ones, were more likely to visit problem-solving tasks repeatedly, increasing their chance of success.

This challenges a common assumption in animal behavior science: that bold, exploratory individuals are more likely to solve new problems. Instead, this study shows that being shy doesn't mean being slow—it can mean being thorough. These mice simply kept coming back to the puzzles, gaining more opportunities to eventually solve them.

"Innovation, it turns out, may be less about who's bold and more about who shows up often enough to get lucky," says lead author Vezyrakis. "Persistence, not just personality, plays a central role in problem-solving."

Shy mice are more persistent problem-solvers, study finds
Presentation of the problem-solving setups in the semi-natural enclosures (top) and arenas (bottom). (1) The four problem-solving setups used in the semi-natural enclosures: (i) omnidirectional slider, (ii) inverted cup, (iii) one-directional slider and (iv) petri-dish. (2) The camera view of the problem-solving box with setup and RFID antenna. (3) The four problem-solving setups and two controls used in the arenas: (I) flip-tube, (II) barred-door, (III) trap-door, (IV) lift platform, (C1) open petri dish and (C2) tube with bedding. (4) The camera view of the arena, with the cage in and all the setups on opposite sides. In (1) and (3), the problem-solving setups are shown in their open (solved) configuration on the left and their closed (unsolved) configuration on the right. Credit: Oikos (2025). DOI: 10.1111/oik.10787

Context changes everything

The research also highlights a bigger issue: where animals are tested can drastically affect the results. In the quiet lab arenas, 60% of the mice managed to solve at least one problem. But in the socially dynamic, real-world-style enclosures, only about 21% did. The same individuals often behaved very differently depending on the environment. This suggests that many lab-based studies might be missing the bigger picture.

"Real-life conditions are messy," explains co-author Guenther. "If we only look at behavior in simplified, isolated lab settings, we risk misunderstanding how animals actually respond to challenges in nature."

Interestingly, mice didn't behave consistently across environments—success in the lab didn't predict success in the semi-natural setting. That difference reveals two key components of : ability (can an animal solve a problem?) and propensity (will it actually try?).

The study suggests that may reveal what animals can do under ideal conditions—but not necessarily what they will do in the wild. To truly understand innovation, scientists need to consider not only the cognitive skills of animals, but also the ecological and that influence behavior.

More information: Alexandros Vezyrakis et al, Effects of behavioural types on the problem‐solving performance of wild house mice under controlled and semi‐natural conditions, Oikos (2025).

Journal information: Oikos

Provided by Max Planck Society

Citation: Timid tinkerers: Shy mice are more persistent problem-solvers, study finds (2025, April 3) retrieved 28 April 2025 from /news/2025-04-timid-tinkerers-shy-mice-persistent.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Wild Asian elephants display unique puzzle solving skills

44 shares

Feedback to editors