Âé¶¹ÒùÔº


This article has been reviewed according to Science X's and . have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

fact-checked

peer-reviewed publication

trusted source

proofread

Nested hierarchies in job skills underscore importance of basic education

Nested hierarchies in job skills underscores importance of basic education
A recent study identifies a nested structure in many professions, where advanced skills depend on prior mastery of broader skills, with significant implications for wage inequality and career mobility in increasingly complex labor markets. Credit: Dong Wook Kim/Pixelism

In many careers, a person must learn foundational skills before advancing deeper into their profession. Computer programmers need a solid foundation in basic mathematics; nurses must gain clinical experience and specialized training to become nurse practitioners; a negotiator's ability to persuade depends on solid communication and active-listening skills.

A published in Nature Human Behavior mapped the dependency relationships between workplace skills using data from millions of job transitions and U.S. workplace surveys. The authors identified a nested structure in many professions, where advanced skills depend on prior mastery of broader skills. This nestedness, they found, has significant implications for wage inequality and career mobility in increasingly complex labor markets.

"We found that many skills aren't just complementary—they're interdependent in a directional way, acting as prerequisites for others, snowballing layer over layer to get to more specialized knowledge," says Moh Hosseinioun, a postdoctoral fellow at Northwestern University and lead author of the study.

The study grew out of a question about how the classifications of blue-collar and white-collar jobs arise, says SFI External Professor Hyejin Youn (Seoul National University), a corresponding author on the study. "In trying to answer this question, we found that these categories emerge around specialization." Knowledge-based work tends to require more time to build specialized skills while physical work is often learned on the job.

"It's like a succession model in ecology—acquiring complex skills requires a sequence of prerequisites," Youn explains. Just as predators depend on prey, which rely on vegetation, which in turn requires soil created by microbes and fungi breaking down rock, unfolds in layers within a kind of mental ecosystem.

"Advanced problem-solving—like solving —first depends on mastering arithmetic, understanding mathematical notation, and grasping logical principles," she says.

"Basic educational skills are the cognitive equivalent of early organisms, creating the conditions in the mental ecosystem for higher-order reasoning to emerge, and are essential for developing the advanced skills that can lead to higher wage premiums."

Nested hierarchies in job skills underscores importance of basic education
Skill dependency hierarchy. Credit: Nature Human Behaviour (2025). DOI: 10.1038/s41562-024-02093-2

This job skills structure isn't itself all that surprising, write the authors in a supplemental , but it has significant societal implications. "We find that skills that are more closely aligned with the nested hierarchy require a longer education, command higher wage premiums and are less likely to be automated," they write.

The nested structure in job skills has become more pronounced over the past two decades, suggesting a possible increase in job polarization as longer, deeper, and more complex sequences of prerequisites may hinder newcomers. Policy interventions may be needed to avoid increasing inequality and polarization in the job market; those unable to access education for foundational skills face barriers to entering higher-wage career paths.

"The more we become specialized and nested, the more inequality and disparity across the labor market will occur," says Youn.

The findings also have implications for education policy. Quick "reskilling" programs may have limited effectiveness without investment in general foundational skills, and moves by universities to remove foundational courses in favor of immediately applicable skills could have unintended consequences for graduates.

The findings also raise concerns about using AI to tackle problems that require foundational skills. "Large language models are unprecedented in how they target fundamental skills," says Hosseinioun. "Is this an opportunity, where some of the layers of the hierarchy might be condensed? Or, if we outsource those fundamental skills, will we become unable to learn more advanced skills?"

The more our collective knowledge base grows, the harder it becomes for any one individual to master a universal set of skills. Our modern economy's demands for ever-more-specialized skills is shaping broader social and economic systems, and the highest-paying skills are locked within a series of prerequisites.

"These structured pathways systematically shape professional development and the socio-economic landscape, driving differences in rewards and career accessibility based on early choice of skill acquisition," write the authors.

"This deeper nested structure imposes greater constraints on individual career paths, amplifies disparities and has macroeconomic implications, affecting the resilience and stability of the entire system."

More information: Moh Hosseinioun et al, Skill dependencies uncover nested human capital, Nature Human Behaviour (2025).

Skill dependencies underlie career paths and have societal implications, Nature Human Behaviour (2025).

Journal information: Nature Human Behaviour

Provided by Santa Fe Institute

Citation: Nested hierarchies in job skills underscore importance of basic education (2025, April 14) retrieved 28 April 2025 from /news/2025-04-hierarchies-job-skills-underscore-importance.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Practical expertise drives salary premiums in the AI sector, finds new study

19 shares

Feedback to editors