Âé¶¹ÒùÔº


This article has been reviewed according to Science X's and . have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

fact-checked

trusted source

written by researcher(s)

proofread

When people are under economic stress, their pets suffer too—we found parts of Detroit that are animal welfare deserts

When people are under economic stress, their pets suffer too—we found parts of Detroit that are animal welfare deserts
This map show the locations of dedicated pet supply stores in Detroit, with circles identifying areas within 1 mile of each store. Credit: Laura Reese,

Nearly two-thirds of U.S. households . More than ever before, companion animals are a part of life—particularly in cities, .

Cities offer access to many resources, but often it's not distributed evenly. Some scholars describe parts of U.S. cities with few or no grocery stores as . Others have identified zones they call transit deserts, where reliable and convenient public transit is scarce or nonexistent.

While the "desert" framing is controversial, there is little disagreement that access to goods and services in many U.S. cities is unequal. I have for the past 15 years, and I have found that the inequities and economic stress humans face affect animals as well.

Recently, University of Nebraska and I explored . We found that pet resources were significantly more likely to be located in ZIP codes with more highly educated residents, , fewer children under 18 and higher median rents.

If households with pets were located mainly in these areas, it would make sense for pet resources to be similarly concentrated. However, while many Detroit households own animals, some parts of the city offer much more access to basic pet supplies and care than others.

Pets come with costs and benefits

Detroit had . Assuming that pet ownership in Detroit resembles the national average, nearly two-thirds of its 249,518 households would have at least one pet, which would total just over 157,000 in the city.

Detroit is more economically distressed than the U.S. overall, with a median household income of $36,140, compared with the . Nearly one-third (30%) of Detroit residents are in poverty, compared with 11.4% nationwide. and are also high.

Detroit's well-publicized economic and fiscal struggles undermine the city's ability to provide services, including animal care and control. Other factors, including and a , add to the animal welfare challenge.

Still, there is good reason for Detroit and other cities to support pet ownership. Studies show that having companion animals in the home . Dog owners report getting . And surveys conducted during the pandemic suggested that animals .

When people struggle to pay their bills, some will surrender pets to animal shelters.

Mapping pet care resources

For our analysis, we compiled data on locations of pet stores and veterinarians from the and Google Maps. We combined it with to see how pet resources correlated with the demographic characteristics of Detroit ZIP codes. We also mapped demand for animal support services, which we defined as dog bites and animal cruelty cases, in each ZIP code.

Our main finding was that Detroit has few dedicated pet stores and veterinary clinics, and these resources are not evenly distributed. Eleven of the city's 26 ZIP codes, clustered in contiguous areas, have no pet stores or vet clinics. They form two large areas: a band stretching across the mid-city, and a zone in southwest Detroit.

We identified 11 specialty pet supply stores that serve Detroit's 243,000 households. Four of these stores are in the downtown/midtown area—which, due to gentrification, has an increasing number of younger, white and higher-income residents.

The other seven stores are scattered around the periphery of the city. This distribution leaves a large underserved area in between, with many residents living a mile or more away from a pet store.

Veterinary practices are not clustered in the same way. While there are very few vet offices relative to our estimated number of pets, these offices are spread relatively evenly across the city and are more likely than pet stores to be located in middle- or lower-income ZIP codes.

Overall, we found that Detroit ZIP codes with more young, single and highly educated residents and higher median rents have significantly more pet resources per capita. More densely populated areas—such as Mexican Town, with high numbers of Hispanic residents, and the city's far east side, with a high proportion of African Americans—have significantly fewer.

Overtasked animal shelters

Lack of access to pet food and supplies is a problem in low-income areas, even in the age of online providers such as Amazon . Shopping online requires internet access and credit card payment. People who can't mail-order pet supplies need physical access to stores.

There's no official data source on Detroit's pet abandonment rates, but the city has a .

In 2022, the four largest animal shelters in Detroit . For comparison, Animal Rescue League shelters in Boston, which has a similar population size, .

The collective 2022 dog euthanasia rate for the four Detroit shelters was about 22%, although it varied widely among the shelters. Animal shelters that are designated "no-kill" generally aim to euthanize , and to do so only when irreparable health or behavioral issues prevent the animals from finding new homes. , a city agency, regularly operates beyond capacity and has to .

Having ready access to pet resources could encourage Detroit residents of all income levels to adopt pets and help prevent relinquishment to shelters.

Getting more help to pet owners

Encouraging more pet-related businesses to open in distressed and underserved areas is an economic development challenge. could support prospective pet store owners and vets who are open to locating in lower-income areas. These organizations typically provide locations for new businesses, offering below-market rents, startup capital and small revolving loan programs.

Incubators are generally run by local governments or public-private partnerships. These organizations could use incentives funded by local taxes to attract businesses in the pet care sector.

Community programs also have a role to play. In high-poverty areas, simply educating people about what kinds of resources are available is a useful starting point.

Many national organizations have programs to help pet owners who are struggling financially. For example, the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals provides services in underserved communities, including . Other nonprofit organizations operate that provide services in areas of need.

In Detroit, organizations such as and provide resources for pet owners, including pet food, outdoor housing, fencing, medications such as heart worm pills and flea preventatives, and low-cost spay and neuter services.

Many food banks and pantries provide —an especially effective way to help both animals and humans. Some home delivery programs, such as Meals on Wheels, to bring pet food and medications to elderly and disabled clients.

Supporting humans and their four-legged companions can promote human and animal health and reduce pressure on animal shelters. Our research shows that cities like Detroit, where many people are financially distressed and don't have easy access to transportation or online shopping, can meaningfully improve residents' lives by helping them meet their pets' basic needs.

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .The Conversation

Citation: When people are under economic stress, their pets suffer too—we found parts of Detroit that are animal welfare deserts (2024, June 25) retrieved 30 April 2025 from /news/2024-06-people-economic-stress-pets-detroit.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Why abusive husbands kick dogs but angry neighbors poison them

7 shares

Feedback to editors